Someday I Will Treat You Good

no platform?

Posted by: Andrew Brown on: 18 August, 2006

Student politics being what they are I’ve left most of mine behind.  The one bit that I’ve always thought sensible was the no platform position for racists.

When I was a student, those further to the left than me argued (and occasionally a bit more than argued) that this should extend to the Conservative Party – who to be fair were winding us lefties up by inviting the apartheid era High Commissioner/Ambassador onto campus.  So I’d have thought that parties that take more extreme positions than the early 1990s Conservative Students had and have a history of racist propaganda might raise the same concerns.

Maybe things have moved on across the piece and the far left no longer support a no platform policy.  Anyway, a bit disappointing to see Ian Page (Socialist Party councillor for Telegraph Hill) seems to be comfortable to share a television studio with Hizb-ut Tahrir.

If I’ve misunderstood Ian’s position I’ll be happy to correct the impression I’ve been left with.

Further Reading:

Newsnight programme from 2003 – BBC

Hizb ut Tahrir’s different faces - Pickled Politics

Hizb ut Tahrir; Controversy over Anti-Semitism – Wikipedia

6 Responses to "no platform?"

Politicalcorrepondent.

These two things are completely different.

If i sign a petition to save a local swimming pool from closure, for example, and a member of the BNP signs the same petition. Does that mean I support the BNP?

I think not.

I don’t agree.

Sharing a platform means exposing and being able, in debate, to show the flaws in an argument of another person/group. Leaving people to do their own publicity leaves them unchallenged.

Hello Tim, do you think that was what was going on here?

Not sharing a platform. My heart and gut agrees with this, but my head questions it. People who say silly things usually look silly. Let’s let them.

The trouble is that we know that the appeal of extremists is growing and I suspect in part thats because we’re seeing a lot more of them in the mainstream and specialist media than in the past.

Leave a Reply

a

Widgets and Stuff



hit tracker



Join Labour - Join the fight for Britain’s future.

del.icio.us lewisham